Harry Potter: books vs. films

Okay, CKR readers, I want to know: how were you introduced to the world of Harry Potter? Were you a reader first? Or did you see the movies? Scholastic has a commercial to introduce new readers to the book series (see below). What do you think?

Guest Reviewer: Leilani V., age 7

The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe by C.S. Lewis

I really recommend this book for other kids because it really takes you into Narnia with Peter, Susan, Edmund and Lucy! This book also brings you with Mrs. beaver, Mr. beaver, Susan, Peter and Lucy to meet Aslan! And it makes you feel like you are hearing the new's that Aslan is in Narnia! And there are a few scary parts! But after you have read a bit of the book you know that everything is going to be OK!

-- Leilani V., age 7

Chains and Wintergirls by Laurie Halse Anderson

How I have never read a Laurie Halse Anderson book before is beyond me. There are just too many good YA authors out there and not enough time to read ‘em all.

These last few weeks, I discovered that LHA is one of those rare authors who transcends the genre pigeon hole, dipping her pen into both YA and historical children’s fiction.
Example #1: Chains (S&S Children's, 2008), an amazing glimpse into the lives of slave children around the time of the Revolutionary War.

The research required to bring a story like this to life is mind-boggling. Anderson tells the story of Isabel and Ruth, two sisters sold to a cruel, wealthy Loyalist couple in New York City during the American Revolution. The history of America’s fight for freedom is a disturbing yet intriguing backdrop for Isabel’s determined fight for her own freedom. The characters are heartbreaking and real, the setting beautifully set.
For readers 6th grade and up, Chains delivers a historic lesson on many levels.

Example #2: the flip side is Wintergirls (Penguin Books for Young Readers, 2009) – an even more intense story, dealing with eating disorders.

18-year-old Lia and her best friend Cassie have had a falling out, but when Cassie turns up dead and alone in a hotel room, Lia fears she knows why. But what she believes is only a tip of the iceberg.

The first-person narrative makes this poignant and sometimes unbelievable story wickedly sharp. As a parent, it’s terrifying to observe how easily the eating disorder can take root in a young girl, and the parallel lines of need: for acceptance and to be the thinnest possible. I wonder what teenage girls think on reading this… for those who are living with eating disorders, I would imagine this would be a tough (but hopefully inspiring) read.

Lia’s obsession with numbers (from the calories in each food item to the numbers on the scale), and poetic description of her inner turmoil are gruesome. She struggles to come to terms with the ghost of Cassie, her guilt and the part she plays in the drama, and her relationships with her family.

Definitely more of a teen book, Wintergirls is a peek behind the curtain of an issue that probably doesn’t get enough of a hard look, and that parents of many teenagers sadly are in denial about.

Both books earn 4 bookmarks on my scale, and put Ms. Anderson on my list of authors to continue reading. Fever 1793, Speak, and Twisted are now in my “to be read” pile.

Have you read either of these books? I’d love for you to weigh in on how you felt after reading about these emotional yet very different stories.